Utah News

EL CAJON (KUSI)- Tristan Diaz is a junior at Granite Hills High School, a young man that has won three CIF football titles and most recently added the first lacrosse title in school history. Also, in the fold not only does he now have four total cif titles in two sports he also is going to play division one lacrosse at the University of Utah.

“Utah reached out over the summer, and after going on a few visits to other schools I went over to Utah to go check it out with my dad that place was amazing. The campus alone was the best I’ve ever seen.” Its a great atmosphere to be in and that played a big effect in my decision.” Diaz said.

Advertisement

“For lacrosse its a lot more fast paced, going on the fly as far as substituting and just thinking on the fly as well. In football you have brakes, in lacrosse your always moving. What also was cool just seeing that environment and how Utah just stands out from other schools. It was really nice to make my decision early and thankfully I had enough choices to have that opportunity it gives me less stress with all the colleges reaching out and everything.”

Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to FOX 5 San Diego & KUSI News.

Given the runaway inflation of track and field performances lately, it’s insanely difficult to qualify for the NCAA outdoor track championships, or, for that matter, the NCAA Prelims.

The top 48 athletes in the country – based on season performances – qualify for the preliminary meet. The slowest time in the 100-meter dash field is 10.29; the slowest time in the 1,500 is 3:37.52 – the equivalent of a 3:54.9 mile.

Advertisement

Given that, it’s worth noting that this year marks the tenth time that BYU has qualified more than 50 athletes (male and female combined) for this weekend’s NCAA West Preliminary track and field meet in College Station, Texas (The East prelims will be held in Jacksonville, Fla.).

Utah State has 21 qualifiers; Utah Valley, 15 qualifiers.

The men will compete Wednesday and Friday, the women Thursday and Saturday.

The top 12 in each event at both regional sites will advance to the NCAA Outdoor Championships, which will be held June 11-14 in Eugene, Oregon.

Four Utah collegians are threats to win an individual national championship – BYU’s Meghan Hunter, Lexy Lowry and James Corrigan and Utah State’s Logan Hammer.

Advertisement

Hunter, a converted sprinter from Provo High who holds the all-classification high school 400-meter state record of 52.59, laid down a 1:58.99 time to win the 800-meter run at the Big 12 Conference championships two weeks ago. It makes her the third fastest collegian ever.

The 800 is one of the most competitive races in the country this year. It will include LSU’s Michaela Rose and Stanford Olympian Juliette Whittaker, winners of the last two NCAA championships, as well as Stanford’s Roisin Willis, a former NCAA indoor champ. Rose is the second fastest collegian ever.

Lowry, a senior from Meridian, Idaho, has the nation’s second fastest time in the 5,000 and the third fastest time in the steeplechase. She broke the BYU school record at 5,000 meters held by Olympian Whittni Morgan, taking it from 15:12.90 to 14:52.93. Lowry ranks fifth on the alltime collegiate list in both the 5,000 and the steeplechase.

Corrigan, who represented the U.S. in last summer’s Paris Olympics, might give up his collegiate eligibility at the end of the season to sign a professional contract.

Advertisement

“It depends how well he runs at NCAAs and USAs,” says BYU coach Ed Eyestone. “As well as he is running now, I would say yes.”

A junior, Corrigan has the nation’s third fastest time in the steeplechase – 8:22.20. A year ago Corrigan ran 8:13.87, which easily eclipsed the American collegiate record of 8:16.23, but it doesn’t count because it wasn’t in a collegiate competition. In his most recent outing, Corrigan, who finished third in last summer’s U.S. Olympic trials, won both the steeplechase and the 5,000 in meet-record times at the Big 12 Conference championships.

Hammer, a junior from Nampa, Idaho, ranks second in the nation in the pole vault with a school-record clearance of 18-8 ¼. Teammates Javin Richards and Marshall Rasmussen (17-4 ½, 17-0 ¼) also have qualified for the prelims.

Utah collegians are strongest, as usual, in the distance and middle-distance events. They have a combined total of 29 athletes ranked in the top 25 of the 800, 1,500, 3,000 steeplechase, 5,000 and 10,000.

Advertisement

One of them is Riley Chamberlain, BYU’s 5-foot-10 junior who can cover a wide range of distances. In the national rankings, she is ninth in the 800, 17th in the 1,500 and 12th in the 5,000.

BYU’s Tyler Mathews and Tessa Buswell, who were in high school a year ago, have had brilliant freshman seasons. Both rank in the top 20 in the 800. Mathews is already the second fastest 800-meter runner in BYU history, with a time of 1:46.19; Buswell ranks eighth with a time of 2:02.26 in an event in which BYU has excelled for years.

Sami Oblad, a converted heptathlete from Stansbury Park, is wrapping up an impressive senior season. She ranks sixth in the nation in the 400-metre dash with a time of 50.49, by the far the fastest ever at BYU.

Carlee Hansen, a senior from Woods Cross who transferred to BYU from North Carolina in 2023, covered 1,500 meters in 4:08.70 en route to a second-place finish at the Big 12 Conference championships, a 2 ½-second improvement over her best time. She fell just short of the school record of 4:08.53 set by Anna Camp in winning the 2021 NCAA championships.

Advertisement

Utah Valley’s Quincy Bonds, who ranks 20th nationally in the 100-meter hurdles, is one of four sisters who are outstanding all-around athletes. Quincy competed for the University of Arizona soccer team for three years before transferring to UVU to compete in both soccer and track. Tiana was a pentathlete for the University of Arizona. Talie was a first-team All-American in the 100-meter hurdles at Arizona. Zoey, a junior at BYU, became the eighth fastest 100-meter hurdler in school history this season with a time of 13.52. She also competes in the heptathlon.

BYU will be without All-American Casey Clinger, who signed a professional contract with Brooks this season and thus is ineligible for collegiate competition. Before leaving BYU, he broke a 40-year-old school record in the 10,000-meter run set by Eyestone, his coach. Clinger posted a time of 27:11.00; Eyestone’s mark was 27:41.05.

Here’s a list of Utah collegians who rank among the top 25 in their events.

100 meters

#25 Gabe Remy, UVU (10.09)

Advertisement

200 meters

#20 Gabe Remy, UVU (20.41)

400 meters

#18 Eli Hazlett, BYU (45.35)

#6 Sami Oblad, BYU (50.49)

800 meters

#17 Tyler Mathews, BYU (1:46.19)

#2 Meghan Hunter, BYU (1:58.99)

#9 Riley Chamberlain, BYU (2:01.42)

#20 Tessa Buswell, BYU (2:02.66)

1,500 meters

#23 Carter Cutting BYU (3:37.31)

#14 Carlee Hansen, BYU (4:08.70)

#15 Lexy Lowry, BYU (4:08.89)

#17 Riley Chamberlain, BYU (4:09.49)

#23 Erin Vringer, Utah (4:10.23)

5,000 meters

#13 James Corrigan BYU (13:25.46)

#16 Joey Nokes, BYU (13:27.89)

#23 Creed Thompson, BYU (13:29.22)

#2 Lexy Lowry, BYU (14:52.93)

#8 Jenna Hutchins, BYU (15:16.95)

#12 Riley Chamberlain, BYU (15:23.88)

Advertisement

10,000 meters

#18 Mohamed Guled, UVU (27:58.41)

#22 Joey Nokes, BYU (28:06.44)

#24 Todd Camren, USU (28:10.91)

#11 Jenna Hutchins, BYU (32:22.98)

#16 Morgan Jensen, Utah (32:33.52)

3,000m steeplechase

#3 James Corrigan, BYU (8:22.20)

#9 Isaac Hedengren, BYU (8:30.01)

#14 Landon heemeyer, BYU (8:33.50)

#15 Logan Garnica, USU (8:33.91)

#18 Peter Visser, WSU (8:35.98)

#23 Abdulsalam Farah, UVU (8:40.47)

#3 Lexy Lowry, BYU (9:18.05)

#9 Taylor Lovell, BYU (9:46.86)

#10 Shelby Jensen, USU (9:48.44)

100 hurdles

#20 Quincy Bonds, UVU (13.07)

4×400 relay

#12 Hazlett-Taylor-Heimuli-Jackson, BYU (3:03.05)

Pole vault

#2 Logan Hammer, USU (18-8 ¼ )

Advertisement

High jump

#16 Aija Hughes, SUU (6-0)

Shot put

#13 Danny Bryant, BYU (65-1.25)

#17 Gretchen Hoekstre, BYU (57-3.5)

Discus

#25 Gretchen Hoekstre, BYU (184-6)

Javelin

#8 Kelsi Oldroyd, UVU (186-11)

#13 Jea Genet, BYU (179-2)

Decathlon

#4 Jaden Roskelley, BYU (8,000)

#9 Ben Barton, BYU (7865)

Newly appointed Utah Tech University President Shane Smeed’s first day on the job — May 1 — happened on the same day as the school’s annual graduation ceremony.

“So my very first day was a commencement — and on my second day, we had three additional commencement ceremonies,” Smeed recently told the Deseret News editorial board.

“So within the first 48 hours of me serving as president, we had the fortunate opportunity to be able to celebrate some of the most exciting days in the lives of our students and their families.”

Smeed’s enthusiasm to be sharing his personal achievements with those of the UTU student body, simultaneously, seems apropos at a moment of historic change — both within the UTU community and across Utah’s higher education system.

Perhaps none of the state’s degree-granting public institutions has experienced the level of growth in recent years as UTU.

During the 2000s, the school originally known as the St. George Stake Academy went from being Dixie State College to Dixie State University and now, since 2022, Utah Tech University.

Even the school mascot has evolved: Rebels to Red Storm to Trailblazers.

Meanwhile, UTU’s enrollment has grown every year since 2013, increasing by almost 60% to over 13,000 students today. Of the school’s 304 academic programs, 60% have been developed within the past seven years.

One reason why UTU has become a popular higher ed destination for many Utahns — 82% are in-state students — is obvious: It’s the most affordable university in the state.

But the school’s 19th president believes UTU’s opportunities extend beyond affordability and program growth.

While some in Utah’s public higher education system view recent legislation demanding budget reallocations as a hostile act against traditional learning, Smeed sees opportunities.

HB265, he counters, “allows us to reinvest money in the places where we think can be impactful — not only in (students’) educational experience, but also in the workforce and preparing them to meet workforce needs and its requirements.”

Additionally, Smeed is anxious to reconnect with members of the UTU community who may have separated themselves from the school. UTU, he said, is their asset.

“It’s an asset for the state. It’s an asset for the community and (Washington County). I see my role as president as every bit ‘externally facing’ as internal — so it’s a great opportunity.”

Prior to Smeed’s hiring, UTU was without a president for over a year after President Richard “Biff” Williams stepped down from the position. Williams, who now serves as president of Missouri State University, was included as a defendant in an ongoing lawsuit alleging Title IX violations in the wake of a vulgar prank.

When asked if those divisive investigations have harmed UTU’s reputation, Smeed said his new job offers him the opportunity to be “a spokesperson for the university” going forward.

“Reputationally, our community will see that our students are probably the best representation of who we are as a university.”

UTU’s polytechnic mission: Preparing grads for the workforce

A Utah native, Smeed served for almost four years as the president of Missouri’s Park University, where he championed education/workforce readiness and expanding the Park campus for military-affiliated students.

He and his wife, Angela, are the parents of three children.

Smeed presided over Park University while also serving as the president of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints’ Platte City Missouri Stake.

While going through the UTU job application process and meeting with Utah’s higher education leaders and members of the Washington County community, “I realized that this was a special place,” he said.

“I was born in Provo, Utah — so this was a great opportunity for me to come back to my home state.”

As an academic, Smeed said he was drawn to UTU’s polytechnic mission. “I believe that it most readily prepares our graduates to meet the workforce needs.”

So why should Utah students choose to attend UTU?

The Beehive State offers a variety of colleges and universities, both public and private, that are relatively affordable and boast a wide range of academic programs.

Smeed is confident that UTU — an open-enrollment institution — is a campus where Utahns can thrive academically, while saving a few bucks at the state’s most affordable university.

“There’s been a big question about whether or not the value of higher education is still there today — but the facts show that a person with a college degree will earn $1.2 million (over one’s lifetime) more than one with just a high school diploma,” he said.

“So if you’re from Washington County, you can expect to make $20,000 more annually than someone who only has a high school diploma.”

Smeed also highlights UTU’s campus growth over the past decade that has transformed the campus. He’s committed to building relationships with the philanthropic community to raise funds and secure scholarships.

Such efforts, said Smeed, will allow UTU students “to graduate with less debt, or no debt, by the time they’re finishing their education — especially for those that are looking for opportunities with internships.

“And then they’re ready to hit the job force and really help with workforce development.”

Historic campus growth; evolving higher ed priorities

Smeed noted that UTU is evolving in real-time even as Washington County’s population booms.

A new performing arts center and a general classroom building are under construction on campus — and a new residence hall was recently completed.

Expect such growth markers and physical footprints to increase in the coming years, he said.

“The growth that’s happening in St. George in Washington County is a tremendous opportunity for us to attract more students from Washington County and within the state,” Smeed said, noting that more than half of the school’s students come from inside the county.

While some have been alarmed by the budget reallocation demands placed on Utah’s public colleges and universities by HB265, Smeed sees the new legislation as an opportunity to better educate and prepare students.

The state-mandated reallocations happening at Utah campuses should not be viewed as cuts — but, rather, reinvestments that will serve graduates well in the coming decades.

“Through our reinvestment plan, we’re looking to add approximately a dozen additional faculty lines to our university.”

UTU’s new president says he is already focused on building relationships with his new faculty.

“My commitment to them is to listen to their concerns and opportunities,” he said. “They’ll see me as a strategic partner — one that can understand the needs of the faculty but can also understand the broader needs of the university.

“My actions will speak louder than my words.”

Smeed is also reassuring UTU students that liberal arts studies and the humanities “aren’t going anywhere.”

Still, there might be opportunities to examine traditional programs and decide if there are ways to incorporate, say, new technologies to make them more applicable for today’s job market.

Smeed’s guiding administrative question: “How can we more strategically place some of those programs in a position where students can graduate, find gainful employment and be able to meet workforce needs, now and then throughout the 21st century?”

‘Trailblazer Nation’: UTU’s athletic future

Varsity sports at UTU made a historic leap last year to NCAA Division I competition.

Most of the Trailblazer teams are competing in the Western Athletic Conference, while the gridiron program is part of the Football Championship Subdivision.

College sports, of course, have undergone historic disruptions in recent years with the emergence of NIL and the transfer portal for athletes.

Given those recent changes, it will take “a bit of time” to build up the school’s athletic program to where it wants to be, said Smeed.

But UTU students and fans can still expect to support competitive teams. Everybody loves a winner.

“So we’re only going to continue to put investment into our athletic programs,” said Smeed.

“We can’t rely on student-athletes to come here without some level of incentive, and so fundraising is a big part of my role as president of the university to find ways to connect with the community, connect with corporate partners and the business community alike, and find ways where they’re interested in supporting athletics.”

UTU’s goal, he added, is to “fill the stadium and fill the arena.”

Has Bronco Mendenhall found a home?

Utah State has had a rough run, and it needs Mendenhall to work his magic as soon as humanly possible.

The program won ten or more games four times in the last 13 seasons – the only double-digit campaigns in Utah State history – and going to bowl games has become the norm.

But three straight losing seasons, and the firing of head coach Blake Anderson just before last year started, made 2024 impossible to turn things back around.

But Mendenhall is used to this. He was great right away at BYU for 12 seasons before running off for the Virginia job. In Year Four, he took the Cavaliers to the Orange Bowl. After taking three years off, he resurfaced in New Mexico, taking over and winning five games with one of the best offenses in the nation.

Utah State might need a little bit. Mendenhall knows what he’s doing, but close to 30 players transferred out, the portal didn’t fill in enough gaps, and this whole thing will be put together with duct tape and a few prayers.

But there’s enough in place to potentially match the four wins of last season. And because it’s Mendenhall, it should be fun regardless of the first year record.

Utah State Aggies College Football Preview 2025

Utah State Aggies Preview 2025: Offense

X CFN, Fiu | CFN Facebook | Bluesky Fiu, CFN

– Bronco Mendenhall isn’t quite bringing over the New Mexico offense that finished fourth in the nation, but he’ll give it a shot. Coordinator Kevin McGiven spent the last several years making the San Jose State offense go. Offense wasn’t a problem for Utah State, finishing sixth in the nation, averaging 468 yards and 32 points per game, but …

– Leading passer Spencer Petras is done, but Bryson Barnes threw 12 touchdown passes and got in enough work last year and at Utah to be ready for the gig. His 348 rushing yards over the last two games might be a glimpse of what’s to come in the Mendenhall attack. However, Arizona transfer Anthony Garcia will get every shot in fall camp.

Advertisement

– Jalen Royals was a special receiver who’ll be a big deal for the Kansas City Chiefs. The transfer portal needs to pick up the slack with Corey Thompson (UNLV), Brady Boyd (Texas Tech), and Demick Starling (WKU) all relatively untested options who’ll get every shot.

– The line isn’t totally starting over, but all five starters will be replaced. Jake Eichorn (BYU) will come in through the transfer portal, and there’s a little experience to play around with.

The job will be to crank up the running game, and it won’t just be Barnes. Miles Davis (BYU) and Javen Jacobs (New Mexico) are quick backs who should each average over five yards per carry.

Utah State Aggies Preview 2025: Defense

– The defense couldn’t do much of anything, even with all the help coming from the strong Aggie offense. The D had a nice pass rush, but it allowed 470 yards and 38 points per game. Defensive coordinator Nick Howell is still around, and …

– The Aggies might have the best safety in the Mountain West. Ike Larsen is back after making 217 tackles, nine picks, and 17 broken up passes over the last three years.

Omari Okeke and transfer Bobby Arnold (New Mexico) will step in at the other slots. The corners might be even better, with Bryson Taylor and Noah Avinger two big-play parts of last year’s New Mexico secondary.

– Top pass rusher Cian Slone is gone to NC State, but Bronson Olevao Jr. is back at one linebacker spot – he was second on the team with 3.5 sacks and 23 tackles – and John Miller should be a bigger tackler in the middle coming off a 52-tackle season.

– The line doesn’t have a ton of experience with Slone gone on one end, but Gabriel Iniguez is a decent run stopper inside, Bo Maile can play inside or as a 3-4 end, and the transfer portal will help with tackle Tyree Morris (Lafayette) an instant starter.

Utah State Aggies Key to the Season

Be way, way better against the run.
The Aggies allowed 5.4 yards per carry and got hammered over 200 yards in seven games.

It’s way, way too tough to hold up when the team is getting crushed in the time of possession battle, and in this way, the offense has to control the clock a bit better. But it’s been years since the program has consistently stopped the run.

Utah State Aggies Key Player

Tyree Morris, DT Jr.
Again, the run defense must be more than just a speed bump. The 6-6, 273-pound Morris might not be huge, but he’s active. He made 65 tackles, two sacks, and five tackles for loss last year for the Leopards, and now he has to be a disruptive force.

Utah State Aggies Top Transfer, Biggest Transfer Loss

Top Transfer In: Noah Avinger, CB Sr.
If it’s not Morris, and if it’s not fellow former Lobo defensive back Bryson Taylor, it’s Avinger, a strong-tackling option for any defensive back spot.

He started out at San Diego State, missed the 2023 season, and then stepped in at corner for New Mexico and stopped everything the porous defensive front didn’t, coming up with 91 tackles and five broken up passes.

Top Transfer Out: Rahsul Faison, RB Sr.
The Aggies have other options at running back and should be okay, but the 5-11, 200-pound Faison would’ve rolled in this new offense. He wasn’t bad in the old one, running for 1,845 yards and 13 touchdowns in two seasons. Now he’s at South Carolina.

Utah State Aggies Key Game

at New Mexico, Oct. 25
No one’s expecting a College Football Playoff national title out of the Aggies, but there are games you can lose, and games you can’t. Bronco Mendenhall losing to the Lobos after his one-and-done era in Albuquerque is one of those the Aggies shouldn’t drop.
– 2025 Utah State Schedule Breakdown

Utah State Aggies Top 10 Players

1. Ike Larsen, S Sr.
2. Noah Avinger, CB Sr.
3. Bryson Barnes, QB Sr.
4. Bryson Taylor, CB Sr.
5. John Miller, LB Sr.
6. Bronson Olevao Jr., LB Jr.
7. Tyree Morris, DT Jr.
8. Miles Davis, RB Sr.
9. Gabriel Iniguez, DT Sr.
10. Omari Okeke, S Sr.

Utah State Aggies 2024 Fun Stats

– 2nd Quarter Scoring: Opponents 186, Utah State 89

– Field Goals: Opponents 20-of-22, Utah State 10-of-16

– Time of Possession: Opponents 32:41, Utah State 27:19

Utah State Aggies 2025 Season Prediction, Win Total, What Will Happen

It’s Bronco Mendenhall, and while that will only go so far on a team that returns four starters and lost just about everyone of note through the transfer portal, he should have the team ready and good enough to at least push for the four wins of last season.

It’s not an awful deal to miss Colorado State, San Diego State, and Wyoming, but it would’ve been nice to miss Boise State, or UNLV, or Fresno State. Making things worse, there’s a trip to Hawaii kicking off a run of four road games in six dates.

The Aggies will beat McNeese and slip by UTEP in the opener. It’ll pull off at least one other Mountain West game – at New Mexico and home against Nevada are most likely – but this is a true rebuilding campaign.

Set The Utah State Aggies Win Total At … 3.5

Likely Wins: McNeese

50/50 Games: Air Force, at Hawaii, Nevada, at New Mexico, San Jose State, UTEP

Likely Losses: Boise State, at Fresno State, at Texas A&M, at UNLV, at Vanderbilt

Utah Utes College Football Preview 2025

X CFN, Fiu | CFN Facebook | Bluesky Fiu, CFN
 
Utah Offense Breakdown
Utah Defense Breakdown
Season Prediction, Win Total, Keys to Season

After a wildly disappointing year, the Utes are about to explode. 2025 Utah season preview with breakdowns, top players and transfers, keys to the season, what will happen, and projected win total.

Almost everyone has an off year.

Advertisement

As good as Utah has been under head coach Kyle Whittingham, it’s not Ohio State, or Alabama, or at the elite of elite programs – it has yet to make the College Football Playoff.

The margin for error is just small enough that something like not having the quarterback situation fully settled can be the difference between blah and fantastic.

Six quarterbacks. That’s how many threw at least 30 passes for Utah over the last two seasons; there wasn’t any continuity to the offense, and that was just enough to go from 2022 Pac-12 champion level to 13-12 over the last two seasons.

Overall, the program is good enough to be dominant in the Big 12, but last year, thanks to that offense, the Utes lost four games by six points or fewer, lost at Arizona State by eight, and didn’t have their mojo in the other two losses.

Utah has gone 2-7 in its last nine games decided by one score. That’s about to change.

And now everyone is about to underestimate the Utes.

Yes, the Big 12 is tough from top to bottom, but no, it’s not better at the higher end than the Pac-12 was before it self-imploded.

Yes, Utah – the program that was a mortal lock in bowl games with a 14-1 record from 1999 to 2017 – hasn’t won a bowl game in seven years.

And yes, Utah has made the pivot to change all of that.

The Big 12 is winnable, and Utah is the team to do it if New Mexico transfer quarterback Devon Dampier – who comes with former Lobo offensive coordinator Jason Beck, and a few other parts – can bring that same firepower from last year’s attack to Salt Lake City.

A conference championship, a trip to the College Football Playoff, and doing some damage once it gets there. This Utah team should be good enough to do it all.

Utah Offense Breakdown
Utah Defense Breakdown
Season Prediction, Win Total, Keys to Season

In 2020, Sen. Daniel McCay, R-Riverton, sponsored Utah‘s abortion trigger bill, which would allow abortions only in the case of rape, incest, substantial impairment of the mother’s health, or if the baby had a lethal birth defect or severe brain abnormality, as the Deseret News previously reported.

While the bill made its way through the state Legislature, “there was a lot of pushback from those who advocate for abortion,” McCay told the Deseret News.

However, “for the most part, it passed through the House and the Senate without much delay,” he said.

The bill was signed into law by former Gov. Gary Herbert, and it sat there, unused until June 24, 2022, when the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade with the Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision.

Before Roe was overturned, Utah was one of 18 states that had passed trigger bills limiting abortion access, which were set to go into effect if the federal decision from 1973 was ever overturned.

As of today, 12 states have banned abortion access, 10 states have imposed stricter gestational limits, 19 states have kept their laws at viability, similar to what was in place under Roe, and 9 states have expanded their laws to include some full-term abortions, per the Kaiser Family Foundation.

McCay was surprised to see Roe v. Wade overturned as soon as it was, just two years after Utah passed its trigger law.

“If anybody thought that Roe v. Wade was going to be overturned as quickly as it was after the bill, I would argue they had a sharper crystal ball than I had,” McCay said.

The trigger law went into effect early on Friday, June 24, the day Roe was overturned. The next day, on Saturday, the Planned Parenthood Association of Utah, along with the American Civil Liberties Union of Utah (ACLU), filed a lawsuit against the bill, claiming it violated the Utah Constitution.

On Monday, June 27, 2022, District Court Judge Andrew Stone granted a temporary restraining order to block the law for 14 days.

Next, Stone issued a preliminary injunction, extending the block until Planned Parenthood‘s lawsuit came to a resolution. Then on August 1, the Utah Supreme Court upheld Stone’s injunction 4-1, which allowed Stone’s lower court block to remain while the case moves forward.

That means abortion in Utah is still legal up until 18 weeks of pregnancy.

Chief Justice Matthew Durrant, the sole dissenter, has held that the preliminary injunction blocking the law should be overturned, and Planned Parenthood should be denied third-party standing, per previous Deseret News reporting.

McCay agrees with Justice Durrant: “The Planned Parenthood case should have failed for lack of standing.”

Of the four justices who voted to uphold the injunction, McCay said, “I think the hard part for them is they’re trying to figure out a way to come up with a Solomon solution that is a compromise between what the law says and what they want to be the outcome, and I think that gets increasingly harder for them to do.”

The case’s first procedural hearing is scheduled for April 2026, Pro-life Utah President Mary Taylor told the Deseret News.

Of the abortion trigger bills passed, a vast majority have been contested in courts

The only states with abortion trigger bills that have made it to 2025 relatively injunction-free include laws in Arkansas, Alabama, Oklahoma and South Dakota. All four of these states have total abortion bans.

However, as the dust has mostly settled post-Roe, these states’ abortion laws are outliers in how similar legislation has gone into effect elsewhere across the nation.

More commonly, abortion-related trigger bills faced legal battles, with Planned Parenthood acting as the plaintiff, claiming the legislation violates state constitutions.

In South Carolina, for example, the state passed a 6-week “fetal heartbeat” abortion trigger bill in 2021. The next year, the law went into effect after the Supreme Court overturned Roe, but it was quickly met by a lawsuit by Planned Parenthood in July.

The South Carolina Supreme Court ruled that the trigger law did indeed violate the state’s constitution, and the state’s legislature proceeded to pass a new version of the law. Gov. Henry McMaster signed the bill into law on May 25, 2023, and later that day, Planned Parenthood filed a lawsuit, claiming the new law was unconstitutional, per The State.

On May 26, South Carolina Circuit Court Judge Clifton Newman blocked the ban from taking effect and ordered the state’s Supreme Court to look at it again.

In August, the Supreme Court declared the 2023 Act constitutional and allowed it to go into effect, per U.S. Law.

On the other hand, several abortion trigger laws have been overridden by states amending their constitutions after the issue was put on the ballot.

In the cases of Arizona, Ohio and Missouri, their more restrictive abortion laws were overturned by a vote among state citizens, and the right to abortion was added into the states’ constitutions.

Three years after Roe was overturned, abortion laws are undecided in only a few states — and one of them is Utah.

Recent lawsuits against state abortion laws differ fundamentally from Roe v. Wade

Roe v. Wade was a civil lawsuit pressed by Norma McCorvey (under the pseudonym, Jane Roe) against Henry Wade, then-Dallas County District Attorney in Texas.

Author of “The Family Roe” Joshua Prager described how McCorvey became the Roe plaintiff to NPR.

Before 1973 in Texas, abortion was criminalized in the state for over 100 years. McCorvey was “a prostitute at this time,” Prager said, adding that by her third pregnancy, she wanted an abortion. She had given up her previous two children for adoption.

Lawyers Linda Coffee and Sarah Weddington filed a lawsuit on McCorvey’s behalf when she was six months pregnant with the Roe baby, per the Brennan Center. They challenged whether Texas’ abortion laws were constitutional.

The case was heard before the U.S. Supreme Court in December, 1971, and in 1973, 7 of the 9 justices agreed that the Due Process Clause implies a right to privacy, and the post-Roe federal legal climate governing abortion was born.

The Planned Parenthood lawsuit against Utah’s abortion law, meanwhile, has a non-person plaintiff.

“Planned Parenthood didn’t have a woman that had been injured. Planned Parenthood is claiming a woman could be injured, and that’s highly unusual for the courts to accept that as what they call ‘standing,’” Taylor said.

In Chief Justice Durrant’s dissent, he explained how plaintiffs must show “distinct and palpable injury that gives (them) a personal stake in the outcome of the legal dispute.”

McCay added, “It has to be a person, having that standing or the potential for injury to bring those claims, and we’ve always kind of followed that process.”

“This is a major departure from third party standing over the last 20+ years,” he said.

However, a large majority of the lawsuits resulting in enjoined abortion laws have been pressed by Planned Parenthood, ACLU and other organizations.

Utah’s Supreme Court held in 2024 that providers, including Planned Parenthood, “had third-party standing to challenge the constitutionality of the state’s ban on behalf of their patients,” a decision which Justice Durrant disagreed with.

“Appellate litigation is undoubtedly too expensive, inconvenient and time-consuming. But if these factors alone are enough to justify the exercise of third-party standing, then we risk a dangerous expansion of that doctrine,” he said in his dissent.

Utah lawmakers feel as though their hands are tied

In a conversation with the Deseret News, McCay said he’s heard talk from fellow lawmakers of following suit from other states and passing a 4-week or an 8-week ban, “but we’re just so afraid of the courts enjoining it and restarting it, so it’s really frustrating.”

He explained that while his constituents want more restrictive laws against abortion in the state, lawmakers are “afraid” that new legislation could cause them to restart in the courts.

“It pains me that we are just kind of sitting on our hands, worried that the court will restart litigation and the litigation process just because they’ve gone one way or the other,” McCay said.

Are the widespread injunctions a sign of judicial overreach?

“It is healthy for the legislature, the judiciary and governors to have tension between them,” McCay said. “And I think that tension, while at times I can find it frustrating, I worry about the day when there isn’t tension between those organizations.”

The system is designed to have tension, he explained. “Sometimes it works in my favor, and sometimes it doesn’t.”

However, while every state started its own individual abortion battle on the same day, nearly all have reached legal conclusions, one way or another, and Utah has largely been left behind in its slow trudge toward the case’s procedural hearing.

“A lot of time is ticking away,” McCay said. “To the advocates against abortion, to their point, a lot of children are dying. And the courts, it seems like, aren’t really concerned about that outcome.”